Hacker News (curated)new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs| show hidden

There is no way to specify a good size in CSS - a size that looks good on current computers will be too big on old computers, and a size that looks good on old computers looks too small on current ones. Browsers and users are the ones who can fix this.


I think your knowledge of CSS might be outdated. What's wrong with the following CSS snippet for example?

    body {
      max-width: 70ch; /* Limits the text column to a comfortable reading width */
      margin: 0 auto;  /* Centers the text column on large screens */
      padding: 1.5rem; /* Prevents text from touching the edges on small/mobile screens */
      line-height: 1.6; /* Gives the lines room to breathe */
    }

As for font size, you can use

    font-size: 1rem;
to respect the browser's default font size.

>What's wrong with the following CSS snippet

The problem is you're imposing your own idiosyncratic preferences on strangers. Your "improvements" cost valuable screen space. I paid good money for my screen space and I don't appreciate designers unilaterally wasting it because they personally think it looks better. The decision of how much (if any) space to spend on padding should be made by the user.


Learn how to resize windows, multitasking, tiling, etc. I prefer to have one monitor in portrait but understand many don’t have or not able.

Useful things to know, but how do they undo a designer wasting my screen space? If you're going to tell me to learn something, it should be CSS. At least Firefox can still be configured to follow its traditional role as "user agent" and allow me to override the bad decisions of designers, by setting toolkit.legacyUserProfileCustomizations.stylesheets and editing chrome/userContent.css . But it would be convenient if more people used the default CSS like danluu.com .

> What's wrong with the following CSS snippet for example?

It doesn't achieve a reasonable readable font size which was presumably the goal. Your padding won't be the right size for all screens either. (And personally I hate excessive line height).

> respect the browser's default font size

The browser's defaults are also bad. But they shouldn't be. The browser is in a position to actually fix this; the webdev isn't.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact | github